Greywater
Dominoes
As Californians
start looking seriously at using greywater for home irrigation, all
roads — or pipes — lead to Art
Ludwig.
By: Ben Preston | October 13, 2009
| 16:45 PM (PDT) | No Comments
http://www.miller-mccune.com/science-environment/greywater-dominoes-3414/
In the mountains above Santa
Barbara, Calif., streams run nearly dry for much of the year. The one
running through an area known as the San Marcos Trout Club, however,
is a bit different. Even in the dry heat of summer, deep pools of cool
water swirl in their sandstone basins as it wends through the little
nook on its way to the ocean.
For Art Ludwig,
founder of Oasis Design - a family-run ecological design company
covering everything from water delivery and disposal to permaculture -
the spot is more than just a peaceful getaway and outdoor office near
his home; it provides inspiration when he is cooking up ecological
solutions and designing small-scale water systems. "Most of what
I've learned has been synthesized in the wilderness," he said.
"The most ecological solution is the most economical."
Finding enough fresh
water has always been a challenge for lawmakers and engineers alike in
the arid American West. With an ever-increasing population and
dwindling mountain snowpack - the spring melts of which supply the
lion's share of water to Western rivers - water resources have
become stretched thin.
According to the
National Drought Mitigation Center's Drought Monitor, most Western states are currently
experiencing drought conditions of varying severity, and have been for
most of the past decade. While in the past those who guide policy have
relied upon creative outsourcing by water officials, overtaxed
reservoirs and river systems have caused them to look more toward
conservation as a way to ensure that their constituents continue to
receive clean, reliable water at their taps.
Although nothing
new, diverting greywater - water from washing machines, showers and
sinks containing far less bacteria than the funky brew toilets and
kitchen sinks emit - for irrigation has become one of the primary
tools in a growing arsenal of conservation methods being examined.
Although concern has been raised about the health effects of using
greywater to water plants, the California Department of Public Health
does not have any cases of greywater-related contamination on
record.
"The most
dangerous thing you can do with greywater is stir a bunch of feces
into it and overload a septic or sewer system," said Ludwig, adding
that sewage treatment systems operating over capacity often dump
untreated effluent into waterways.
Already in place in
Arizona, New Mexico, Texas, Montana, Nevada and other Western states,
standards spelling out how best to use water were also passed by the
California Building Standards Commission on Aug. 4. Although
California state Sen. Alan Lowenthal had already developed a set of
greywater standards, a fourth year of statewide drought prompted the
California Department of Housing and Community Development to push for
emergency greywater standards at the Building Standards
Commission.
"The reason we did
the emergency standards is because in February, [Gov. Arnold
Schwarzenegger] declared a drought situation and directed departments
to do whatever they could to enable water conservation," said Doug
Hensel, deputy director of Housing and Community Development. The
result was an intense series of meetings with stakeholder groups that
helped shape the standards that were finally adopted in
August.
"The average
person wouldn't know that much about [installing greywater systems],
so we made [the standard] kind of like a recipe to
follow."
By all accounts a
vast improvement over the limited standards California had before this
year, Ludwig nonetheless looked to Arizona's laissez-faire greywater
rules - in place since 2001 - calling it the model to emulate. The
desert state's user-friendly two-page brochure makes it easy for homeowners to figure out
how to use greywater safely, without impinging upon how they go about
designing their systems.
Ludwig also advised
New Mexico officials when they adopted standards similar to
Arizona's in 2003.
"Every site is
different, and so are people's [water usage] habits," said Daniel
Wilson, a Santa Barbara-based landscape designer who has begun
installing greywater diversion systems in conjunction with fruit tree
planting. Despite California's relatively late entry into simplified
greywater regulation, some 1.7 million greywater systems are already
installed in homes across the state -there are nearly 8 million
nationwide - and until recently, only 200 of them were legally
permitted.
"It [was] an
abstinence-only greywater system. It pushed people to do it
illegally," said Ludwig, who stressed that while permitting is
unnecessary for simple diversion systems, standards are important to
ensure proper use and installation.
His Web site notes
the difficulty of challenging the status quo and remaining street
legal - on one page he writes: "The more ecologically you live, the more illegal
it is." And for that reason he provides both code-friendly
information for
prospective practitioners and a series of ideas for making end-runs
around recalcitrant bureaucrats.
"State guidelines were very complicated and turned a lot of people
off. People found that the standards were too difficult to deal with,"
said Laura Allen, a member of Oakland-based Greywater Action, a group heavily involved in the
stakeholder process that got California's revised standards off the
ground.
Now, as in many
other Western states, California homeowners with greywater systems
diverting washing machine effluent to irrigate onsite trees do not
require a permit. This is where Ludwig and others experienced in
building greywater systems come in, providing vast informational
resources for existing and would-be greywater users. Not as simple as
collecting laundry water in a bucket to pour on a garden, only certain
types of plants - mostly fruit trees and flowers, but not vegetables
such as carrots and lettuce - can benefit from greywater
irrigation.
It also requires
that homeowners, if they weren't already doing so, use biodegradable
laundry soap, as traditional soaps would harm the plants. "As long
as you're using the right products, [greywater irrigation] makes a
lot of sense," said Allen, who has been using greywater on her kiwi
and apricot trees and berry bushes for a decade.
On the whole, greywater use seems to have attracted a passionate group
of individuals, and a wealth of information is available for both
do-it-yourselfers and those who are simply curious.
When it comes to
greywater, all roads on the information highway lead to Ludwig, who
has been researching and designing the uses and impacts of greywater
for nearly 20 years.
"Greywater is part
of a system that would allow us to exist on 90 percent less
resources," he said, explaining that his work reflects a belief that
water use is connected to a number of other things, including energy
use and ocean water quality. Transporting water over hundreds of miles
and even pumping it over a mountain range, the State Water Project is
California's single most prolific user of energy, consuming about
three percent of all the electricity used in the state, by EPA
estimates. (The National Resources Defense Council puts that figure
significantly higher, at 20 percent).
"This issue lies
across the fault line of two world views. One is build it up to code
and it's ok, and the other is to look at water depletion and climate
change as well - the big picture," Ludwig said.
In a dilapidated
trailer next to their house, Ludwig and his college-age daughter,
Maya, usually aided by an intern or two, work tirelessly to compile
videos, pictures, and new data for their seemingly
endless www.oasisdesign.net. From the mountainside vantage point of
these cramped quarters - which are perennially cluttered with
charts, official documents, and the odd bowl of fruit - the distant
Pacific Ocean is visible through a couple of small windows, reminding
them how connected everything really is.