Can 'Slow
Investing' Remake America's Food Industry?
By JUDITH D.
SCHWARTZ Friday,
Sep. 11, 2009
http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1921889,00.html
Could the trouble
with money be that it's...too fast? Sure, you may think, it leaves
your pocket too fast. But Woody Tasch, a longtime investment
professional and founder of the Slow Money Alliance
(www.slowmoneyalliance.org)
, is talking
not about anyone's spending habits but money as a system: as money
increasingly functions as electronic blips shuttling from screen to
screen in speculative transfers, it becomes divorced from its effects
in the real world and less reflective of actual wealth. The result, he
says, has been bad for our economy, the planet and the individual
investor. The antidote, according to Tasch, is expressed in the
subtitle of his book, Inquiries Into the Nature of Slow Money: Investing as
if Farms, Food, and Fertility Matter.
The Slow Money
Alliance, set up as a nonprofit, brings the tenets of the Slow Food
movement (buying local) to finance - exploring investment vehicles
that re-circulate within the local economy, minimize environmental
impact, stress diversity over monoculture, and earn decent returns.
Tasch wants to give investors a stake in "restorative economy,"
building the food and ecological infrastructure on a community to
community basis.
"The Slow
Food movement has helped raise consciousness about where food comes
from, down to the farmer," says Tasch. "We're doing the same
thing with money - where does it come from, and, when you spend or
invest, where does it go?" In Tasch's vision that covers
everything from seed companies to farms to markets and
restaurants.
Tasch has devoted much of his career to merging asset management and
philanthropy. Most recently, for 10 years up to 2008 he was Chairman
of Investors' Circle, a network of venture capitalists, angel
investors, and foundations that uses private money to promote the
shift to a sustainable economy. Here, Tasch incubated the ideas (and
ideals) that became Slow Money.
This week, in Santa Fe, marks the official launch of this
tortoise-beats-the-hare economic model. While Slow Money
Institutes-forums for building regional stakeholder networks - have
taken place in Grafton, Vt, Point Reyes, Calif., Bellingham, Wash.,
and Madison, Wis., this gathering brought together 300-plus
participants representing at least four countries drawn from
investment, philanthropic, academic and entrepreneurial
circles.
The individual businesses he's zeroing in on may be small, but Tasch
is thinking big: "We're setting out to build an organization of
one million Americans to invest in food systems around the U.S."
He envisions "catalyzing investments of $25 million a year or
more as a first step." Though he is only now starting to raise
money, Tasch says the response to his model has been "extremely
heartening."
Slow Money differs from traditional socially responsible investing in
that the partnerships are deeper, as the Alliance works to build not
just a firm's profitability but also supportive structures. For
example, rather than just lending money for, say, a farmer's barn,
they would look at the farmer's other infrastructure needs, such as
storage, retail outlets, transport to markets, etc. Also, inherent to
the model is the notion that part of the "return" is the
social and environmental benefit a company represents.
So what about the "slow" part? For the investor looking to
realize returns, will you ever get there? Yes, says Mark A. Finser,
Founder/General Partner of TBL Capital in Sausalito, CA. As a
"snapshot of a short period of time" the conventional
investment model may look good, but "I fundamentally believe that
in the long run there will be better returns" with Slow Money
type investments, he says. This is particularly true, he adds, when
"we look at investing as an extension of our lives and values."
He notes that RSF Social Finance, which invests in enterprises
committed to improving society and the environment and where he served
as President and CEO and is now Chairman of the Board, realized a
steady 3%-4% average over 25 years and has continued to grow despite
the current downturn.
The Slow Money investment model - with its local, hands-on
orientation - gives business owners the means to stay true to their
mission during critical growth periods, says Tom Stearns, President of
High Mowing Organic Seeds, an organic seed company in Wolcott,
Vermont, who participated in Vermont's Slow Money Institute in
November, 2008. Traditionally, when a company takes investment money,
that means setting itself up to sell, he says. "How else do
investors make money? But if you're mission- or place-based, that's
the first thing to go out the window," he says. "I think a
new generation of investors also doesn't want that to happen. They're
thinking, 'Hey, I don't want to invest in you if you're going to sell
to Coca Cola in three years.'"