THE COLOR OF
MONEY
THE
PERMACULTURE CREDIT UNION MIGHT BE AMERICA'S GREENEST BANK
http://sfreporter.com/stories/the_color_of_money/5411/
"We are
looking to a more sustainable model-and we do see ourselves as an
antidote to a lot of [Wall Street] excess," Brendan Miller, PCU
Chairman Brendan Miller says.
By: Corey Pein 03/10/2010
Within a month of
becoming president of the Santa Fe-based Permaculture Credit Union
(www.pcuonline.org)-a unique financial institution based, as the
name suggests, on eco-friendly principles-Don Sarich had his first
encounter with a skeptical government regulator.
"One of the regulators said to me, 'Don't worry, you can get a
job somewhere else because we're going to shut you down.' That's
a true quote," Sarich says. "I thought, 'Now I have to prove you
wrong.'"
That was in 2003. Times were different then. That February, President
George W Bush had introduced his ideal of an "ownership society."
His Federal Reserve chairman, Alan Greenspan, would soon cut interest
rates to 1 percent, making it absurdly cheap for financial
institutions to borrow money-and lend it out at much higher
rates.
The Fed's easy credit policy helped create the appearance of rapid
growth and unprecedented prosperity in a nation that no longer
produced many tangible goods, preferring to leave that task to poorly
paid laborers in faraway countries. The easy credit enabled record
bank profits and, for executives, a number of private jet purchases.
For average Americans, it encouraged runaway spending on needless
luxuries and a quickly mounting pile of debt it now seems the nation
may never repay.
Then it all went bust.
Since the early stages of the global financial crisis in 2007, 243 US
banks and credit unions have failed, according to the
online Bank
Implode-O-Meter,
which offers "Your play-by-play for the end game of modern banking."
Their assets-or what's left of them-have been consumed by bigger
fish. The federal government essentially invented a few trillion
dollars, by printing more money and borrowing against hoped-for future
growth, and used it to try to stimulate the credit markets, in what
increasingly looks like a hopeless attempt to revive the illusory
"ownership society."
Across the country, mailboxes once stuffed with pre-approved credit
card offers began filling with foreclosure and past-due notices.
Meanwhile, back in Santa Fe, PCU has more than doubled in size. And of
the approximately $15 million in loans the young credit union has
made, only $23,000 worth has been written off as uncollectable, Sarich
says.
"One was a foreclosure," he says. "The member passed away, and
the relatives couldn't get rid of the house in time."
This year will mark PCU's 10th anniversary. In the past couple of
years, Sarich says, the regulators that once predicted the credit
union would shut down have been more understanding of the institution
and its goals.
Next to the mad, money-hungry risk-taking on Wall Street, PCU is a
fundamentally conservative operation that pays modest dividends to a
like-minded membership. It shuns the latest short-term profit-oriented
financial products.
"Why would I be chasing derivatives, when the core business is to do
loans for your members who are doing things that are sustainable?
There's a difference between what the financial markets have done
and what the credit union is doing," Sarich says.
In another sense, PCU is anything but conservative: It seeks to prove
that a financial institution can grow while embracing real
environmental sustainability.
"I wouldn't really call it an experiment. It's more challenging
the financial system," Sarich says.
PCU specializes in making loans that traditional banks and credit
unions avoid: a loan to construct a new Earthship or off-the-grid
home, or a second mortgage to pay for solar panels, for
instance.
"I refinanced [an Earthship mortgage] that was paying 21 percent
[interest] in New Mexico," Sarich says. "The person had good
credit. He had a good equity position. I couldn't find a reason the
21 percent was being charged, besides greed."
Another example of the permaculture approach to finance: PCU charges
lower interest rates on car loans for fuel-efficient vehicles. So
they'll cut you a break if you're buying a Prius-but if a Hummer
is what you covet, look elsewhere.
PCU Board of Directors Chairman Brendan Miller says there's a reason
most Santa Feans haven't heard of the credit union.
"We have been under the radar sort of intentionally," Miller says.
"We have a limited ability to take new members."
That's because of a regulatory requirement that PCU maintain a 6
percent capital ratio-money it keeps in reserve to back customers'
deposits. Such a rule keeps consumers' money safe, but for a small
money co-op that refuses investments it deems unethical, it also makes
growth difficult. Sarich says a new customer recently wanted to move
$90,000 to PCU from Bank of America. To maintain the proper ratios, he
could only accept $5,000.
Miller says PCU relied on grants to fuel its past growth. But for its
anniversary, the credit union will be soliciting donations in order to
permit the expansion of its member base. (Alternatively, PCU could
raise rates on existing members to create a profit-but the board has
chosen not to.)
To be sure, PCU's credit offerings are somewhat limited.
"If you want to do a first mortgage, you may have to get in line
until we can absorb that," Miller says.
And while PCU does make student loans, it has made only one business
loan, an arrangement with Santa Fe Farmers Market.
Nor is PCU fully buffered from the outside world. Last month, PCU
reported an $8,800 operating loss-but not because somebody was late
on their Earthship payment. Rather, the loss came from PCU's
investment with a larger nationwide credit union consortium, which was
more exposed to nationwide problems.
Overall, Miller says, PCU stands to benefit from public anger at Wall
Street.
"Our values are to reinvest in our communities, where our members
are, in the bioregions where we live. We are looking to a more
sustainable model-and we do see ourselves as an antidote to a lot of
that excess," Miller says. "We do see [the financial crisis] as an
opportunity for us. And we have weathered it quite
well."
PCU By the Numbers
* Members: 1,009
* Estimated percentage of
members with A+ credit scores: 80
* Assets (including loans and
investments):
$5.65 million
* Liabilities (including member
deposits):
$5.47 million
* Number of loans outstanding:
257
* Number of loans that are more
than two months delinquent: 6
* Average monthly income from
fees, per member: $2.17
* Number of employees: 3
* Total employee compensation,
including benefits (2009): $122,100
* Federal bailouts received:
0
* Average CEO compensation at financial
institutions that took federal TARP bailout money: $3.4
million
Sources:
PCU statements of financial condition, National Credit Union
Administration, AFL-CIO Executive PayWatch, PCU President and CEO Don
Sarich